• en

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant

- View Restaurant Hours
Restaurant Hours
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant in Salem
4.7
50
Direction

104 E Market St 47167-2033, Salem

Questions/Answers
Overview
Cuisine
Questions and answers

What are the weekly drink and food specials?

Taco Tuesday is great. $.99 domestic draft beer and cheap ?

Review
Add rating:
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
KM
Kylee Miner
google
11.21.2018
5

We love this place. The servers are amazing as well as the food. We have ordered all kinds of different things and we never have a problem. I highly recommend this restaurant.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
CG
Cristhopher Guzmán
google
09.19.2018
5

In Salem,Indiana this is the best Mexican and/or Tex-Mex restaurant that I would recommend. The food tastes most authentic -although if you are Mexican you would quickly notice the lack of spices in it. But still it's comparable to other places I have been. I think there's a lot of variety in the menu. And when you ask for a non-alcoholic beverage it comes in a huge container. So don't worry about asking for a large or a small sweet iced tea because going to be huge. Me encanto

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
1bluepatches
google
09.16.2018
5

Big portions very yummie! Friendly people

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
TJ
Tammy Jones
google
08.23.2018
5

Very great area, awesome service, food was extremely tasty and fresh.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JR
Janet Rachel
google
07.25.2018
5

Excellent food and generous servings and reasonable prices. Nice atmosphere. Good servers. My only complaint is their use of cilantro! I despise it. I guess they have not heard that some people have a certain gene that makes the stuff very nasty to them. Please, can you just put the cilantro on the side for those that want it!?!? Our favorite place to go to in Salem!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
RM
Ricky Malone
google
06.03.2018
5

Very quick service,great selection on menu! Highly recommend!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
GL
Greg Lautzenheiser
google
05.27.2018
5

Best Mexican restaurant in that I've been to in Indiana. Best I've been to outside of San Diego! Service was as good as it gets! Highly recommended.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
HH
Heidi Howard
google
05.26.2018
4

Delicious authentic Mexican food to eat while dining in a quaint and cozy space!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
RJ
Robert Johnson
google
05.18.2018
5

This place is really good 👌 I think is my second favorite out out the Mexican place it Nashville Indiana I recument this place

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
RS
Roy Sherrill
google
03.20.2018
5

Really good and you get alot for your money!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
MC
Monica Copeman
google
02.12.2018
5

Really great quality mexican fare. Staff is on it! They want to make you happy and are very quick with the service. Wide variety of drinks, beers and their wonderful margaritas. Friendly atmosphere and in the heart of downtown Salem. Afterwards, take a casual stroll around the square and visit some shops. Enjoy! 🍺 🍷 🌹

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
AS
Amber Sparkman
google
01.27.2018
5

best Mexican food in town! The special sour cream sauce is amazing and the salsa is my favorite

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
KH
Kay Hamilton
google
11.17.2017
5

Great food, service and clean. Awesome place to eat. Very good margaritas.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
KH
Kimberly Hall
google
11.17.2017
5

My son and I had lunch here on September 19, 2019. I have to say this was the best Mexican food I have ever ate in my life, everything was amazing. The atmosphere and service was excellent, thank you Amber! We will definitely be back.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
MH
Matthew Herbert
google
11.15.2017
5

El Maguey's was good we have not eat there in a while but decided to go there to eat I had the shrimp enchiladas. They were pretty good, we will come back again.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
TG
Trinity Gooch
google
11.11.2017
5

Loved it, amazing food. Great decor! My friends & I took some wild photos there! We did agree that we absolutely LOVED the mural on the back wall of El Maguey!!! Our waiter was a good friend of mine and he took pictures for us and made sure we were well taken care of!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JR
Jason R
google
11.06.2017
5

Excellent food, sweet deals!!! Friendly staff. New upstairs area opened the weekend we were there, very nice!!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
SH
Selena Herbert
google
09.09.2017
5

I love most Mexican restaurants but El Maguey has a great atmosphere. The style of deco makes the meal even better. I love how they serve beverages in unique old fashioned milk containers. The salsa is different than the usual tomato based ones at other popular Mexican franchises, but it's delicious! Definitely a great place to dine!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
tt
top this
google
09.03.2017
5

we visit often! The food is great and the staff is always friendly. I love taking visiting family there!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
MD
Megan Decker
google
08.16.2017
5

This place was awesome! Great service and great food. Loved the huge drink crafts. Their sweet tea is great too! Highly recommend.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JC
Jessica Chamberlain
google
07.01.2017
4

I love this place. Great atmosphere. Food is always hot and tasty. Ask for the hot salsa and mix it with the mild.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
SK
Shawn Koch
google
06.15.2017
5

The food was great! Very busy night but food came quickly!!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
SC
Sean Cox
google
06.13.2017
5

Great food, great service. Even though they were really busy, food was fast and hot. I will definitely be dining there again.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
mosierworks
google
05.27.2017
5

Great Food. Awesome atmosphere

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
VB
Vicki Bennett
google
05.24.2017
5

We go here often. It's one of our favorite Mexican restaurant options in the area. Always yummy food, no matter what you order. Drinks are good, beer is cold, food is hot, salsa and chips are good. Would recommend this spot! Love the wooden ceilings here too. Atmosphere is good

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JT
JASON TREESH
google
05.11.2017
4

For a Tuesday night they were packed and the kitchen couldn't keep up. Kind of a long wait. The food was good a worth the price.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
AJ
Andrea Johnson
google
05.10.2017
5

The service was very good as well as the food. There was live entertainment it was very good. Had a great time. We were celebrating my Granddaughters birthday.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
AR
Adrian Ramirez
google
04.14.2017
5

Nice location, very good food and of course the micheladas were awesome. Some kind of noisy music on the background but overall was good service.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
KH
Kevin Hopkins
google
03.11.2017
5

5 stars. Family loves this place. The food has so much more flavor than other Mexican restaurants. The only drawback is what to order, everything looks fantastic. Menu is so extensive, staff friendly, management efficient. Large dining area, cheap beer. What more could you ask for?

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
DG
Daniel Gummersheimer
google
02.25.2017
5

What, loved it. Two days in the roll for lunch. Awesome wet burrito!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JS
Josie Stamper
google
02.04.2017
5

We loved it. Great waiter and good food. Maybe a frozen machine next time?

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
Aaron
google
02.03.2017
5

Family owned business. One of my favorite places to eat. Can’t wait for the new Terrance to open up!!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
GK
Geralyn Klein
google
01.13.2017
5

Very nice Mexican restaurant on the square in downtown Salem, Indiana. Authentic Mexican food. Huge portions enough to share. Our first visit here and we will be back. Thank you for a great first impression.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
TP
Tiffany Pulkowski
google
01.06.2017
5

Great food, quick service, and amazing salsa! Lunch portions are huge!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
SR
Sondra Rippy
google
11.27.2016
2

I had the half slab of ribs. They were over cooked and dry. My Grandson and I are big BBQ rib eaters and he couldn't eat them either. They were more like a piece of tough beef jerky. The only reason I did not say anything at the time was because it was a special occasion for a Granddaughter. Dining on the roof was very nice.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
RM
Renee Mills
google
10.21.2016
5

Service and food was great! At a good price.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
EC
Emily Cozart
google
08.17.2016
5

I love Ethan! Best server ever!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
KE
Karl Eastman
google
07.18.2016
5

We had an Amazing meal on the New terrace part of the restaurant, overlooking the square.Great wait staff.Awesome experience.Loved the view.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
WR
Wendy Rowe
google
07.14.2016
1

Chewy no taste chicken under what tastes like Campbell's cheddar soup in flour tortillas this was a combo of chimacunga still waiting for my glass of water and guacamole

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
mvieck68
google
07.08.2016
5

My wife and I just ate here for the first time and we both enjoyed it very much. The decor and atmosphere is very good. The place was clean and service was excellent. The salsa was great and food was very good as well. We plan on coming back very soon. Much better than the other Mexican restaurant in town.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
PS
Paula Strong
google
05.17.2016
5

Great service, great food, and love the atmosphere!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
NA
No Apologies
google
05.04.2016
5

Wish I could come more often. It gets better everytime. Loved the drink carafes, decor, and food. The service was excellent. They did good hiring local staff for servers.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
DJ
Dana Jackson
google
05.01.2016
5

The food was some of the very best Mexican we have ever had. Great tasting and worth the hour drive. They served drinks from carafes with straws. No one ran out! The 55 cent margaritas were the bomb, with lots of tequila in them. We had a large group of 10, some well traveled, but everyone was impressed with this place. 5 stars.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JR
Jason Roberts
google
04.07.2016
5

Excellent staff. Love eating here. Great menu, and with the rooftop open the atmosphere is enhanced exponentially. One of the few places you will eat that you might not need a refill on your drink.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
CJ
Crystal Johnson
google
03.23.2016
5

Always love the food and great service 💙 Our favorite place to eat

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JB
Jackie Barr
google
03.09.2016
5

The atmosphere was wonderful, the music great and the food outstanding. First time was definitely a charm! Can't wait to go back!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
DS
Dylan St. Clair
google
03.06.2016
3

Order for drinks and food were not correct. Food was ok and took a bit to get our order due to staff confusion. I give it more of a pass than usual due to it being a holiday.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
CD
Crystal Davis
google
03.01.2016
5

Great food and environment!! The owner is a super nice lady and the staff is great! The new rooftop deck is amazing!!!

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
JH
Jackie Henry
google
01.23.2016
5

Five star place to dine. My favorite place to eat in this town. Food is great, waiters are great, atmosphere is great, and margaritas are excellent. Highly recommend.

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
LP
Linda Patt
google
01.23.2016
2

Food was plain. I grew up in Southern California so I know a good Mexican restaurant when I taste one!

Phone
18128830098
Last update: 2024-03-14 15:04:31
FREQUENT SEARCHES LEADING TO THIS PAGE

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant Salem,El Maguey Mexican Restaurant Salem Indiana, El Maguey Mexican Restaurant menu

4.7
50
Open
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant in Salem

104 E Market St 47167-2033, Salem

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!